A couple of days ago, I was sitting in my room, doing some useless, abortive stuff as usual, when one of my friends started a topic of discussion. There were 7 of us, say A, B, C, D, E, F and I. I do not remember how exactly the discussion started but one thing is for certain, that night was a very long night. All of us had our own views and none was willing to yield to the others’ arguments. The main topic of discussion was this: Should or should not Indians go abroad and settle there if it is more convenient to them? Effectively, it is the same as whether Brain Drain has a negative impact on the country or not.
B, being the root of most jokes cracked in the group, especially in connection to a certain girl named M, was the main target here. I was the only other guy supporting his claims. All others tried to refute our arguments resulting in a tedious, lengthy, intense battle to impose our beliefs on each other. When I joined the discussion, it had already heated up a bit. A and C were providing very strong opposition to B, at times going to the extent of ridiculing his statements and disdainfully ignoring his views. Poor B was attacked personally as well.
Heres what happened.
12:30 am
B: “I want to lead my life happily and comfortably. I am going to do whatever it takes to achieve that. I am not happy in this country, so I want to get out of here and go to a place where you get what you need.”
I didnt find anything wrong or offensive in what he said. Besides, my beliefs were in somewhat parallel terms. So, I started arguing for him. A had a problem with what B said.
A: “ It is because of people like you, ****ers like YOU, that the change, which was supposed to happen in this country is not happening. Do you know how many Indians go abroad and settle there every year? If all those ****ers had stayed behind and worked for our country, instead of boosting the GDP of other countries, India would have been in a better state today. And why arent you happy here? All of us are.”
I: “Dude do you really think all those people staying back would have helped the country? The porblem with this country is how it runs. Efficient people are not running it. Corrupt polticians are everywhere. All maggots who have no knowledge about the world whatsoever, just plenty of money to spare. The system is full of fatal flaws and is a total failure. They say the government is by the people. Do you think we can do anything to alter the way it is functioning? The answer is no, because the government is mainly elected by illiterate people who fall into their traps of false promises. And the government blissfully ignores the horrible literacy rate in this godforsaken country.”
At this point, E inturrepted and started saying something about peasants( the word horribly mispronounced) in the USA to which nobody paid much attention.
The argument continued with nobody reaching a conclusion and no one yielding.
1:30 am
C: “Dude, if all the people who went and settled in other countries stayed back, the literacy rate would have been better and if learned people like IITians and ‘NITians’ enter politics instead of running behind money, there would have been a better government and considerable change would have taken place.”
I: “Dude it is easier said than done. Do you think you are going to enter politics after finishing college?”
B: “If you give a beggar in India a good house and a sexy wife in London, do you think he is going to go or is he going to say this is my country, i do not want to leave it?”
C: “Why would I give a beggar here a good house in London, you dumbass!!!”
At this point, an isolated, moronic retard who, unfortunately, dwells close to my room, after hearing all the commotion so late in the night, entered the scene. Let us name him SUCKER.
SUCKER: “Abbey idhar sun. If all this discussion doesnt give you any joy, whats the point of the discussion?”
Then, he gave an expression of pride and when everyone ignored him, he left the room.
After hearing the noise coming from our room, G entered and wanted to argue against B and I.
G: “See man, if you go to Amul and ask people not to throw plastic near the footpath, dont you think it is gonna make a difference after sometime? It might not make an impact on most people, but atleast one or two will realise that what they are doing is not right. It is upto our hands to take responsibility and spread awareness in our country. Change is a gradual process and change will come. You cant expect it come overnight.”
Then, he went on to speak about how he was responsible for having a shopkeeper fined by the consumer court and other shit like that.
2:30 am-E and F were asleep by now
B: “ If God gives a beggar in India a good house and a sexy wife in London, do you think he is going to go or is he going to say this is my country, il do not want to leave it?”
D: “ WTF are you talking about? How would a beggar get a house in London all of a sudden?”
I: “A hypothetical situation dude. Dont you think he would choose a path more convenient to him? If he has got nothing out of this country, wouldnt he want to go out if hes got a chance?”
B: “ Just answer my question dude. If God gives a beggar in India a good house and a sexy wife in London, do you think he is going to go or is he going to say this is my country, i do not want to leave it.”
C: “Of course he is going to go.”
B: “So, if and when you guys get opportunities in other countries to lead your life better, why wouldnt you want to go? All this country concept is bullshit dude.”
Now, D was pissed off.
D: “All you do is Slog, see M. Slog,see M. Sleep. What other better work do you have? You dont have the right to talk about anything we do. You are a ****ing traitor. Get the **** out of here. Atleast we will try to improve this country.”
The next one hour went by as a discussion was going on about how shit is prevalent in this country and nobody is ready is clean it, most people think it is not their job and go out of the country to make their lives better, not caring for those who are directly affected by the shit.
3:30 am
G: “Guys, let us do this. From now on, whenever we go to Amul and see someone throwing plastic on the streets, let us make it our duty to remind him/her of the ill effects of plastic littering. Let us see if there is any change after 2 weeks. OK?”
I still do not understand why this guy was so obsessed with Amul.
Anyway, when everyone agreed, G claimed that the discussion had been concluded (I do not understand how) and suggested we all go to bed. So, G left.
But, we continued anyway. B continued with his Beggar Philosophy. I said I believe in my principles and I am going to follow them. A appeared to be highly ‘patrioic’ and said we can clean the shit that is sinking our country. As for C and D, they said they are going to stay here no matter what. So, we went to bed a 4 30 am, not because the discussion had ended, but because we were too tired and sleepy to continue any further.
A dialogue from one of my favourite movies, Scent of a woman, comes to my mind when I look back at this argument. Al Pacino as Lt.Col. Frank Slade says, “ I have come to the crossroads in my life. I always knew which the right path was. Without exception I knew. But, I never took it. You know why? It was too damn hard.” I have to disagree with him on this. Whenever a path is hard, it cannot be the right path. The right path is one which conveniently and easily brings happiness in life.
Adios.


A disastrous silhouette. Would have been better if the Sun was rising in the background.